Almost 30,000 community service orders breached in 11 years, figures show

Almost 30,000 breaches of community sentences have been recorded over 11 years, data obtained by the Scottish Conservatives shows.

Of those who breached community payback orders (CPOs), 8,078 resulted in the offender being handed another community sentence while 7,956 led to a custodial sentence being imposed.

The Tories said the freedom of information data showed “the SNP’s soft-touch justice system in action”.

Figures showed 29,544 breaches of CPOs between 2012-13 and 2023-24.

Justice Secretary Angela Constance has recently spoken of the need to “shift the balance from custody to justice in the community” as part of measures to deal with prison overcrowding.

Earlier this year, Constance announced there would be an independent review into sentencing and penal policy in Scotland.

The Conservatives have called for more stringent sanctions for offenders who violate CPOs.

Sharon Dowey MSP said: “These shocking figures are yet more evidence of the SNP’s soft-touch justice system in action.

“Given the increased use of community payback orders, the very least the public expect is for offenders to carry out the sentence imposed on them.

“Where there has been a breach, offenders should be properly punished rather than let off the hook. It defies belief that so many are simply having another CPO issued.”

She added: “It sends a clear message to criminals that there are no consequences for failing to pay their dues, which makes a mockery of the justice system.

“These figures are yet another example of John Swinney’s Government pandering to criminals and betraying victims.”

A Scottish Government spokesperson said: “Community payback orders are a flexible and robust disposal, with a consistently lower reconviction rate compared to short prison sentences.

“That’s why the budget for 2025-26 includes an additional £11m in support for community justice services and ongoing work to further enable a shift away from the use of custody.

“Where a CPO has been breached, it is up to the independent courts to decide the most appropriate outcome based on all of the circumstances of the case.

“Ultimately, this may include the imposition of a custodial sentence”.