Support for Livi boss Martindale ahead of Hampden hearing

Scottish Football Association set to determine whether David Martindale passes criteria for fit and proper club officials.

David Martindale faces Hampden hearing on Tuesday. Alan Harvey via SNS Group
David Martindale faces Hampden hearing on Tuesday.

By Kevin Scott and Sheelagh McLaren

An abrupt end to David Martindale’s tenure as Livingston manager would be “grossly unfair”, the club’s chief executive said on Monday.

John Ward was speaking to STV News ahead of Martindale’s Hampden encounter on Tuesday with the Scottish FA, who are yet to determine whether he passes their fit-and-proper test.

The 46-year-old Livingston boss was sentenced to a six-year jail term in 2006 following drug and money-laundering charges.


But Martindale has enjoyed the best introduction to management imaginable since stepping up to replace Gary Holt as Livingston boss in November.

Livi won their first eight games under his charge before drawing twice with Celtic.

The West Lothian side are also just 90 minutes away from winning silverware following their 1-0 League Cup semi-final win over St Mirren on Sunday.

Livingston face St Johnstone in the final at Hampden on February 28.


Ward said: “Football can be fickle and fans can be quite harsh with each other but I’ve barely seen a post that wasn’t supportive.

“We’ve put what we think is a pretty good submission together and, you know, hopefully tomorrow the impetus will keep us going and it would be very difficult if it went the wrong way, how we would handle it, what we would do about it.”

Ward says the club also wants to send a message to children in the local area that they can turn their life around if they get into difficulty.

He said: “The club represents an area that is socially deprived, there are issues around education, so if we’re going to be telling 20 per cent, or 25 per cent, of our young people that if you get into trouble or if you make some wrong choices there’s no hope for you, you’re never going to be able to develop what your initial plans were, or what your goals were when you were a kid – that’s a powerful message to be sending to kids.

“If we’re showing it the other way round and we have David as an example of what focus and changing your life can do, I think that’s a very strong message to kids.

Hannah Bardell, MP for Livingston, has submitted a letter to the SFA, urging them to look positively upon Martindale at the hearing.

She said that allowing him to continue in his role as manager of the West Lothian club would send a “very strong message about what is possible and that there is life and opportunity after crime”.


Bardell wrote: “I hope you and those at the SFA considering David’s ability to undertake his role will consider that he stands out as a figure who is proof that it is possible to turn your life around, be rehabilitated and move forward positively.

“Rehabilitation is a vital part of a civilised society and I know the SFA try to be a positive force in that regard.”

Meanwhile, a professor renowned for his work on the Hillsborough disaster has also written an unsolicited letter to SFA chief executive Ian Maxwell, which has been published by Livingston.

Phil Scraton, of Queen’s University Belfast, said he felt compelled to enter a submission after watching television coverage of Martindale’s impending case.

Ahead of the hearing, Scraton wrote in his submission: “Granted remission, it is clear in David Martindale’s case that the punitive element of his sentence had been realised.

“He admitted his guilt and in prison he took the opportunity to gain a university degree.

“His release laid the foundation for continuing rehabilitation, which clearly has been successful. Almost a decade on, his progress at Livingston FC and his appointment as the club’s interim manager demonstrates the board’s confidence in his employment as a ‘fit and proper person’.”

Scraton, whose work on the Hillsborough disaster spanned three decades, says much of his research, teaching and publications have focused on prisons, penal reform and prisoner rehabilitation including in-depth research in Scotland’s prisons.

He wrote: “Throughout my work, I am aware of the institutional difficulties faced by prisoners leaving prisons unscathed by the difficulties they face inside and the uncertain futures they experience in the community.

“I expect that Livingston’s confidence is based not only on the success of the club under his management but also on how he has adjusted to working with players, all involved with the club and the media.

“His media statements have been contrite and show humility in the face of exceptional public scrutiny.

“I believe that within its grasp the Scottish FA has the opportunity to acknowledge David Martindale’s remarkable personal and professional transition.

“By accepting he passes the ‘fit and proper person’ test, the SFA not only, rightfully, would recognise his transition but also demonstrate to other authorities and employers that those who have committed serious offences, through their own efforts and with the support of others, can turn their lives around.”

Holyrood pays tribute to ‘extraordinary’ Duke of Edinburgh

Prince Philip, Queen Elizabeth II’s husband, passed away on Friday morning at Windsor Castle.

Yui Mok - WPA Pool via Getty Images

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon led tributes to the late Duke of Edinburgh at Holyrood.

The Scottish Parliament was recalled on Monday for only the sixth time in its history so as MSPs could show their respect to Prince Philip in a motion of condolence.

The 99-year-old, Queen Elizabeth II’s husband, passed away on Friday morning at Windsor Castle.

The Duke and the Queen were married for more than 70 years and Philip dedicated decades of his life to royal duty, serving the nation at the monarch’s side.

STV News
Royal: Holyrood paid tribute to the Duke of Edinburgh.

Following a one-minute silence in remembrance, Sturgeon said: “The tributes paid to the Duke of Edinburgh over these last three days show the affection in which he was held here in Scotland, across the United Kingdom and indeed around the world.

“On behalf of the people of Scotland I express my deepest sympathy to Her Majesty The Queen, who is grieving the loss of her strength and stay, her husband of almost 74 years, and also to the Duke’s children and to the wider Royal Family.”

STV News
Holyrood: A minute’s silence was held for the Duke of Edinburgh.

The First Minister highlighted his life-saving efforts during the Second World War, and like so many of his generation the Duke had “endured difficulties and faced dangers that generations since can barely comprehend”.

Sturgeon described the relationship between The Queen and the Duke as a “true partnership”.


She said: “He faced the additional challenge of being the husband of a powerful woman at a time when that was even more of an exception than it is today.

“That reversal of the more traditional dynamic was highly unusual in the 1940s, 50s and 60s, and even now isn’t as common as it might be.

“Yet, the Duke of Edinburgh was devoted to supporting the Queen – they were a true partnership.”

Chris Jackson via Getty Images
Braemar Gathering: The Queen, Prince Philip, Prince Charles and the Duchess of Cornwall.

The FM said she enjoyed speaking to the Duke about the books they were reading when she would stay at Balmoral.

She added: “He was a thoughtful man, deeply interesting and fiercely intelligent.

“He was also a serious book worm, which I am too, so talking about the books we were reading was often for me a real highlight of our conversations.”

Sturgeon highlighted his interest in industry and science and said he was “far-sighted” in his early support for conservation.


She added: “Indeed, as far back as 1969 in a speech here in Edinburgh he warned of the risks of ‘virtually indestructible’ plastics.

“Of course, in 1956 he founded the Duke of Edinburgh Award scheme which now every year provides opportunity, hope and inspiration to more than one million young people in more than 100 countries across the world.”

Hulton Archive via Getty Images
Just married: Princess Elizabeth and Prince Philip on their wedding day.

The First Minister said “it is right that our parliament pays tribute” to the Duke.

She added: “In doing so, we mourn his passing and we extend our deepest sympathy to Her Majesty The Queen and her family.

“We reflect on his distinguished war-time record, his love and support for The Queen and his decades of public service to Scotland, the United Kingdom and the Commonwealth.

“Above all, we celebrate and we honour an extraordinary life.”

The Scottish Conservatives’ Ruth Davidson said she couldn’t imagine what “it is like to be married to someone for 73 years”.

She added: “And I can’t imagine what it is to have to get up and face every future day without them – what that absence feels like.

“And I think the recognition of the enormity of such a loss is what has led so many over the past few days to look past the titles and the 41 gun salutes and have such a sense of feeling for Her Majesty on such a human level.”

Davidson described the Duke as a “dashing young naval officer” who went on to become a “palace moderniser”.

She said: “He was a man that was born before the discovery of penicillin, before the creation of the United Nations or the invention of the television or the jet engine.

“But a moderniser he was in life, as well as in work. How many men in the 1950s gave up their job for their wife’s career?”

She also recalled how he had once asked former Scottish Tory leader Annabel Goldie about her underwear, at an event in Holyrood held to mark Pope Benedict’s visit to Scotland.

Davidson said: “Seeing Iain Gray [former Scottish Labour leader] sporting a tie in the papal tartan, the Duke turned to Tory leader Annabel Goldie to ask if she had a pair of knickers made out of this.

“Quite properly, Annabel retorted, ‘I couldn’t possibly comment, and even if I did I couldn’t possibly exhibit them’.”

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar said he’d “never had the privilege” of meeting Prince Philip, so didn’t have a personal anecdote to share.

However he retold the story of a man called Jon Watts, who was jailed at the age of 17.

Sarwar said: “Jon recalled ‘there was lots of alcohol and no aspirations for people like me’, is what he said.

“But while in prison he came across the Duke of Edinburgh’s award, which he said gave him a new sense of direction.

“He camped out for his first award not on a Scottish mountainside, but in a tent on the artificial grass of a prison football pitch.

“Jon went on to get the bronze, silver and gold award while serving a six-year sentence.

“The skill he learned during the programme was cooking, and upon leaving prison he set up his very own catering business, now helping other young people to learn new skills and find jobs. ‘It saved my life’, Jon said last week.

“That’s just one life that the Prince helped save; there will be countless others from different walks of life.”

WPA POOL/POOL via Getty Images
Edinburgh: Members of the 105th Regiment Royal Artillery fire a 41-round gun salute.

Patrick Harvie, co-leader of the Scottish Greens, also paid tribute despite the party wishing for an elected head of state.

Highlighting all the lives lost during the coronavirus pandemic, he added: “Today is a moment to extend our thoughts to Prince Philip’s family and to all those who are grieving for their loved ones in a spirit of respect for the equal value of every human life.”

Scottish Lib Dems leader Willie Rennie recalled a meeting in which Prince Philip asked him about a “little blue man” badge he used to wear.

He said: “The Duke of Edinburgh spotted it at a reception. He bounced up, demanding to know what it was. ‘To show support for the prostate cancer campaign’, I said.

“He looked at me closely. He says, ‘have you got it or are you against it?’ Then he bounced off again.

“The engagement was only 30 seconds long, but it has stayed with me and to be retold numerous times over the years.

“It seems that he left lasting impressions with so many others too. Some less repeatable than others, but so many were fun and memorable.”

Man arrested after blaze rips through community centre

Emergency services were called to a charity-run eco village in Findhorn in the early hours of Monday morning.

BrIan Smith via Jasperimage
Blaze: Extensive damage to community centre following fire.

A man has been arrested after a fire ripped through a community centre in Moray. 

Emergency services were called to The Park, an ecovillage run by the Findhorn Foundation, in the early hours of Monday morning following reports of a fire.

Six appliances were sent to the scene alongside specialist resources in order to extinguish the blaze.

Police have confirmed a 49-year-old man has been arrested in connection with the incident.


A Scottish Fire and Rescue Service spokesperson said: “We were alerted at 2am on Monday, April 12 to reports of a fire within the Findhorn Foundation Park, Findhorn, Forres, Moray.

“Operations Control mobilised six fire appliances as well as specialist resources to the scene to extinguish the fire.

“There were no reported casualties.

“Firefighters left after ensuring the area was safe.”


The foundation said “extensive damage” has been caused to the community centre and main sanctuary at the eco village.

In a statement on Facebook, Findhorn Foundation said: “We’re so sad to tell you that there was a serious fire here in the early hours of the morning, causing extensive damage to the community centre and the main sanctuary. 

“Thankfully no-one has been hurt.”

A Police Scotland spokesperson said: “We were called around 2.05am on Monday, 12 April to a report of a fire at a community centre in The Park, Findhorn, Moray. 

“A 49-year-old man has been arrested in connection with the incident and enquiries are ongoing to establish the full circumstances.”

William pays tribute to ‘extraordinary’ grandfather Philip

The Duke of Cambridge says Philip's life was defined by service to country, Commonwealth, Queen and family.

Duchess of Cambridge via Kensington Palace
Prince Philip with his great-grandson Prince George.

The Duke of Cambridge has paid a heartfelt tribute to his grandfather, the Duke of Edinburgh, describing him as an “extraordinary man and part of an extraordinary generation”.

William’s statement spoke of Philip’s relationship with Kate and expressed his gratitude for the “kindness he showed her”.

The future king summed up the duke saying his “…life was defined by service – to his country and Commonwealth, to his wife and Queen, and to our family”.

Over the weekend the duke’s four children spoke movingly about the loss of their father and how the Queen is stoically coping after her husband of 73 years died peacefully on Friday.

Phil Walter / Staff via Getty Images
Prince Harry, Prince Phillip and Prince William in 2015.

The duke said about Philip: “My grandfather’s century of life was defined by service – to his country and Commonwealth, to his wife and Queen, and to our family.

“I feel lucky to have not just had his example to guide me, but his enduring presence well into my own adult life – both through good times and the hardest days.

“I will always be grateful that my wife had so many years to get to know my grandfather and for the kindness he showed her.

“I will never take for granted the special memories my children will always have of their great-grandpa coming to collect them in his carriage and seeing for themselves his infectious sense of adventure as well as his mischievous sense of humour!


“My grandfather was an extraordinary man and part of an extraordinary generation. Catherine and I will continue to do what he would have wanted and will support The Queen in the years ahead. I will miss my Grandpa, but I know he would want us to get on with the job.”

Kensington Palace tweeted the duke’s statement together with a touching new photograph of a young Prince George with his great-grandfather Philip.

George, a future King, was pictured sat by the duke’s side on the box seat of a carriage, as Philip held the reins and a whip.

Dressed in shorts and a knitted jumper, George is holding open a picture book in the taken in Norfolk in 2015.

The Duke of Sussex also paid tribute to his grandfather, saying he was “a man of service, honour and great humour”.

In a statement issued through his foundation Archewell, Prince Harry said: “My grandfather was a man of service, honour and great humour. He was authentically himself, with a seriously sharp wit, and could hold the attention of any room due to his charm—and also because you never knew what he might say next.

“He will be remembered as the longest reigning consort to the Monarch, a decorated serviceman, a Prince and a Duke. But to me, like many of you who have lost a loved one or grandparent over the pain of this past year, he was my grandpa: master of the barbecue, legend of banter, and cheeky right ‘til the end.


“He has been a rock for Her Majesty The Queen with unparalleled devotion, by her side for 73 years of marriage, and while I could go on, I know that right now he would say to all of us, beer in hand, ‘Oh do get on with it!’

“So, on that note, Grandpa, thank you for your service, your dedication to Granny, and for always being yourself. You will be sorely missed, but always remembered—by the nation and the world. Meghan, Archie, and I (as well as your future great-granddaughter) will always hold a special place for you in our hearts.

“‘Per Mare, Per Terram.’”

Many Scots pessimistic over summer holiday travel hopes

Concerns over isolation and possible resort restrictions were given as the key reasons to choose a staycation over a foreign trip.

STV News

Many Scots remain unconvinced that they will be able to book a holiday abroad this year.

STV News spoke to people around Aberdeen city centre on Monday to find out if they are confident planning a break in the sun later this year.

Concerns over the requirement to isolate on return and possible resort restrictions were given as the key reasons to choose a staycation over a foreign trip.

UK transport secretary Grant Shapps said that those in England “could start to think” about booking overseas travel as restrictions eased across the country.

However, the Scottish Government said “where possible” it will look to adopt a four-nation approach, but the position in Scotland “remains that it’s not permitted to travel abroad without an essential reason”.

Three in court accused of human trafficking offences

Two men and a woman appeared at Hamilton Sherriff Court on Friday.

Police Scotland
National Human Trafficking Unit police executed search warrants in North Lanarkshire.

Three people have been charged in connection with human trafficking offences after specialist officers raided two properties in North Lanarkshire.

National Human Trafficking Unit police executed search warrants on Dalriada Crescent and Jerviston Court, Motherwell, on Thursday as part of an ongoing investigation.

Two men, Floreau Sandu, 50, and Florian Pietraru, 39, and a 25-year-old woman, Teodora Rotaru, appeared at Hamilton Sherriff Court on Friday, April 9.

All three faced charges under the Human Trafficking and Exploitation (Scotland) Act 2015.


They are accused of being involved in the running of a brothel and procuring or attempting to procure a woman or girl to become a prostitute.

They entered no plea and were committed for further examination and released on bail.

They are expected to appear in court at a later date.

Coronavirus: No further deaths as cases rise by 199 overnight

According to NHS boards across Scotland, 154 people are currently in hospital with confirmed or suspected Covid-19.

BlackJack3D via IStock
Covid-19: The fight to stop the spread of the deadly virus goes on.

A further 199 cases of coronavirus have been recorded in Scotland, the Scottish Government has confirmed.

While cases are often lower following a weekend, the figure is the smallest number of new cases since 70 were recorded on September 14.

No additional deaths have been reported.

The death toll of those who tested positive stands at 7630, however weekly figures on suspected Covid-19 deaths recorded by National Records of Scotland suggest the most up-to-date total is now more than 10,000.


The daily test positivity rate is 2.4%, up from the 1.8% reported on Sunday when 250 cases were recorded.

Of the new cases reported on Monday, 67 are in the Greater Glasgow and Clyde region, 28 are in Lothian, 28 are in Lanarkshire, and 21 are in Fife.

The rest of the cases are spread out across six other health board areas.

According to NHS boards across Scotland, 154 people are currently in hospital with confirmed or suspected Covid-19. Out of those, 21 patients are in intensive care.


The Scottish Government also confirmed that 2,668,723 Scots have received their first dose of a Covid-19 vaccine, an increase of 11,145 from the day before.

A total of 590,174 people have received their second dose, a rise of 21,299.

Parts of Scotland experience ‘coldest April night’ on record

Sunshine, snow and hail combined for a twist on an April shower this weekend.

Getty Images via Getty Images
April cools: Areas across the country recorded the coldest April night in around 30 years.

Parts of Scotland have recorded the coldest April night in around 30 years with temperatures dropping to almost -10C.

People across the country were left baffled when sunshine, snow and hail combined for a twist on an April shower this weekend.

On Saturday night the mercury fell to -6C in Aberdeenshire and as low as -8C in the north and west Highlands.

Temperatures dropped even lower on Sunday night, with Monday morning being an April record-breaker for some areas,


Tulloch Bridge in the Highlands was the coldest spot with a low of -9.4C recorded, which is almost a whole degree lower than the record for April. Records here go back almost 30 years.

Even further south the temperatures hit the extreme end of cold for April with a low of -7.4C in Tyndrum, -4.5C in Islay, -4.3C in Edinburgh and -4C at Bishopton in Renfrewshire. The lows in Tyndrum and Islay look like new records.

While Scotland has had local records, the all-time record has been safe, with -15.4C recorded back in 1917 at Eskdalemuir in Dumfries and Galloway.

STV Meteorologist Sean Batty said: “Cold and snowy weather in April and May can come as a big shock, but this part of spring can be very volatile with some huge day-to-day swings in temperature.


“So far this year it seems we’ve lacked the extreme warmer spells where we can get the BBQ and sun loungers out, and it’s been more typical to be bundled up against an icy wind.

‘I’ve got bad news for those of you hankering after the other end of extreme, I don’t think we’ll be hitting the 20s until May.’

STV Meteorologist Sean Batty

“In the last few weeks, we’ve had some abnormally cold conditions but we’ve not been alone with central and western Europe colder than usual – including Spain where there was some extreme heat recently.

“Most of the country had some snow showers during the weekend, and where skies cleared at night, there were some very low temperatures.

“As we go through this week it will feel warmer by day with temperatures getting back into double digits by the end of the week, but frosts will still occur by night, although temperatures won’t be as low as recent nights.”

Sean added: “I’ve got bad news for those of you hankering after the other end of extreme, I don’t think we’ll be hitting the 20s until May.”

SPFL matches moved to noon ahead of Duke’s funeral

Nine matches will move ahead of the Duke of Edinburgh's funeral, which is due to take place at 3pm.

Craig Foy via SNS Group
SPFL: Matches moved to noon on day of Duke's funeral.

Football matches scheduled for Saturday will now kick off at midday to accommodate the Duke of Edinburgh’s funeral, the SPFL have said.

Prince Philip died on Friday morning at the age of 99 at Windsor Castle. 

The Duke’s funeral will take place on Saturday at St George’s Chapel, Windsor at 3pm.

Following discussions with the Scottish FA and other stakeholders, the SPFL announced on Monday that nine games will now begin at 12pm. 


However it is not yet known if the fourth round of the Scottish Cup will take place this coming weekend.

One lunchtime game and four 3pm matches have been scheduled, with Rangers vs Celtic due to kick off at 4pm on Saturday.

In the Scottish Championship, Alloa Athletic vs Raith Rovers, Arbroath vs Ayr United and Dunfermilne Athletic vs Queen of the South will all begin at noon. 

Scottish League One games that will move will be Cove Rangers vs Falkirk and East Fife v Peterhead. 


In the Scottish League Two, Annan Athletic will take on Brechin City, Cowdenbeath will face Stirling Albion, Edinburgh City will meet Queen’s Park and Elgin City will go up against Albion Rovers at midday.

How I found peace in plants amid Covid and the housing crisis

Having spent lockdown in a cramped flat with no garden, plants have been a wholesome respite.

STV News
A display of Ketsuda's houseplants she has collected during the pandemic.

I have left the west end of Glasgow five times this past year. Times dined out: zero. But I have breathlessly collected 16 houseplants.

Instead of stepping out of bed and falling into a cesspit of Covid despair, I check my plants. Whilst coffee brews, I make the first rounds, gently inspecting leaves, hoping for new growth. How much can a leaf unfurl in the hours of sleep? Not much, but I can tell.

Before the pandemic, I already felt the masochistic pangs for a home and garden of my own. Days into the first lockdown, the urgency and scarcity of space, indoors and out, was inescapable. Particularly in cities, space is a prism of wealth, class, and access — inequalities driven to extremes during the pandemic.

In urban life, the city is an extension of your home. Tight quarters and high rents are a trade-off for a flourishing life lived in parks, cafes, pubs, and restaurants. Many like myself do not have a car or garden. So what happens when the city shutters?


I covet space and fantasise about its different forms: personal, green, storage, single use. To me, wealth is room to breathe. It is lounging alone in a private garden, rather than a heaving public park. It is having the resources to bunker down in a roomy house, then fleeing to holiday across travel corridors.

STV News

Homeownership is a pipedream without generational wealth. There would be no ‘generation rent’ without low wages, unemployment, and a competitive market inaccessible without the bank of mum and dad. Paying someone’s second mortgage so that you will never afford your own is a bitter pill.

At just over 500 square feet, my flat squeezes in myself, my husband, and our perilously stacked belongings. Our bedroom is a bed and one end table wide. The dining table is shoved into a corner, now relegated to office space. We eat every meal on the sofa.

Enter houseplants. My gardening story starts, as I imagine many do, apathetically. I owned a cycle of plants that I killed and replaced after a year, maybe more. Last summer one of these survivors had long outgrown its pot.


A cursory Google of “how to repot a plant” led to obsession: endless research, YouTube videos, local plant swaps, creating new plants from propagation, and, of course, buying plants. The interplay of light, water, and soil was suddenly something fascinating.

Gardening offers gentle unpredictability. Nurturing houseplants is soothing, and in a climate as cloudy as Scotland’s, it is a slow burn. Indoor plants are more finicky than their real world counterparts. Their challenges are just difficult enough, because, ultimately, the stakes are low. Plants can be replaced.

STV News

That said, I have never been outdoorsy. But when I stroke a newly unfurled leaf, I have a strange urge to send silent thanks to nature for what it has created. I am honoured to have had a hand in it. Plants flourishing under my care is a wholesome joy I desperately needed.

The passage of time has been brutal this last year — unmoving, endless, a thing to be endured. Yet, emerging through Covid misery, is a bit of excitement.

With gardening, I look at the future in terms of years and growing seasons to come. I marvel at other people’s plants, dreaming of how big and lush my plants could grow to be. Finally, something to look forward to.

Ketsuda Phoutinane

Ketsuda Phoutinane is a freelance food and features journalist based in Glasgow.

Follow Ketsuda on Twitter.

Pass the Mic


Pass the Mic works with women of colour who are experts in their field – educators, academics, researchers, campaigners, policy-makers, community activists, writers, workers, carers and many more. 

It aims to make a tangible change across media in Scotland by increasing the representation of women of colour who participate in it, and by improving how women of colour and the issues that impact them are talked about.

You're up to date

You've read today's top stories. Where would you like to go next?