Communities on the island of Cumbrae warn that proposed cuts to ferry services could have a “devastating” impact on its economy and essential services.
CalMac, which operates sailings between Cumbrae and Largs, plans to reduce sailings by 25% from March to address safety concerns with the current timetable.
However, residents and businesses say the changes will threaten jobs, tourism and access to healthcare.
The ferry currently operates up to four times an hour, but tight turnaround times mean vehicles and foot passengers embark and disembark simultaneously.
CalMac says this has led to a number of near misses, some of which they believe could have had serious consequences.
Fleet management director Louis De Wolff said continuing the current timetable is no longer safe.
“We’ve had a significant number of near misses, some very serious,” he said. “It’s simply not sustainable to continue operating in this way. Safety has to be the bottom line.”
He added that CalMac understands local concerns and insists the revised timetable will still meet demand.
“We’re always open to talking to communities, and we’ll continue those discussions so people understand why these changes are necessary,” he said.
STV NewsBut islanders say the impact will be felt far beyond the ferry terminal.
Ross Newton, who is preparing to open a new cafe in Millport, fears the reduced service will deter visitors during the crucial summer season
“The tourism economy here is seasonal and very fragile,” he said. “You earn your money in the summer. If fewer people come over, businesses won’t make the same revenue, and that ultimately leads to job losses. It has a ripple effect across the whole island.
“We’re at their mercy. They are subsidised and have no competition – we’re not.”
The Cumbrae Community Council says residents who rely on the ferry as a lifeline service could also face serious difficulties.
Although the crossing takes only around ten minutes, breakdowns have resulted in vehicle queues lasting up to four hours.
STV NewsAngus Campbell from the council said the community is “really angry” about the proposals.
“It’s a huge impact on the whole community – all sectors: healthcare, education, business, commuters, the elderly, and in particular the tourist businesses which underpin the economy on the island.
“The island has to have summer visitors. This could have a devastating effect on the sustainability of businesses. It’ll cause huge queues on both sides, and it will put people off coming.”
He raised concerns about patients travelling to and from hospital appointments on the mainland.
“What happens if someone coming back from chemotherapy has to wait hours in a queue? That’s terrifying.”
STV NewsThe group also accuses CalMac of failing to properly consult with the community.
“They claim they’ve consulted with us; none of the sectors have had engagement with CalMac. They are showing total contempt in terms of meaningful consultation.”
“What we’re seeing is a blatant disregard for island communities, the government, and the taxpayer,” Mr Campbell added.
The group is now calling on transport secretary Fiona Hyslop to reject the proposed timetable changes.
Follow STV News on WhatsApp
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
